Home / Blog / Fighting Back Against Fake Reviews: A Law Firm’s Guide to Tackling Fake Reviews

Fighting Back Against Fake Reviews: A Law Firm’s Guide to Tackling Fake Reviews

A law firm’s online reputation is one of its most valuable assets. Prospective clients are increasingly turning to review platforms like Google Business Profile, Yelp, and specialized legal directories to vet and select legal counsel. Positive reviews act as powerful endorsements, building trust and credibility. Conversely, negative, fake, or spam reviews can be devastating, eroding years of hard-earned professional standing overnight.

For law firms and businesses across all 50 U.S. states, the threat of fake reviews is real. The good news is that you are not powerless. With a strategic approach, a clear understanding of your ethical obligations, and timely action, you can effectively combat fake reviews and protect your firm’s integrity.

The Critical First Step: Due Diligence and Ethical Compliance

Before you take any action, you must perform due diligence to determine if the review is genuinely fake or from a disgruntled client or consultant. For law firms, this step is critically intertwined with your ethical duties.

1. Prioritize Confidentiality and Ethical Rules (ABA Model Rule 1.6)

For attorneys, the rules of professional conduct—specifically the obligation to maintain client confidentiality—must guide your response strategy. The American Bar Association (ABA) advises that attorneys should exercise extreme caution and often avoid directly responding to negative reviews to prevent the disclosure of any information related to a client’s representation. Even if the reviewer discloses confidential details, your response cannot confirm the attorney-client relationship or compromise the client’s private information.

Action Item: Consult your state’s specific Rules of Professional Conduct and any relevant state bar ethics opinions on responding to online reviews. When in doubt, defer to silence over an ethical breach.

2. Consult Firm Records

Examine your client and consultation databases. Do the reviewer’s username, initials, or the details in the review align with any current, former, or potential client?

Real-World Example: A divorce attorney in Florida receives a one-star review claiming she botched a felony case. A check of her records confirms she only practices family law and has never represented anyone in a felony matter. Verdict: High probability of a fake/spam review.

Spotting the Red Flags: How to Identify Fake Reviews

While your instincts are often right, a systematic analysis of the review and the reviewer’s account can provide the concrete evidence needed for removal requests.

Red Flag Category	Indicator of a Fake Reviews
Reviewer Account History	A “one-off” account with only one contribution (the negative review) or an account used solely to target a handful of competitors.
Suspicious Timing	A sudden, uncharacteristic deluge of one-star reviews posted in rapid succession or over a short, regular interval.
Reviewer Details	Sarcastic, offensive, or generic-sounding usernames (e.g., “Angry Client,” “Law Firm Sucks”).
Substance and Content	The review discusses services your firm does not offer, contains generic complaints, is full of glaring spelling/grammatical errors, or is clearly off-topic (e.g., a personal vendetta unrelated to the firm’s services).
Competitor Promotion	The review directly or indirectly promotes a specific competitor’s firm.

The Action Plan: Steps for Fake Reviews Removal and Damage Control

Once you have determined the review is likely fake or spam, you need to act quickly and methodically.

1. Preserve All Evidence (The “Digital Fingerprint”)

Before taking any other steps, you must secure the evidence. Fake reviews often disappear quickly, so preservation is paramount, especially if you consider future legal action.

Action Item: Take multiple, dated screenshots of the entire Google Business Profile page showing the review, the reviewer’s profile, and the full URL in the address bar. If possible, use professional preservation software (like Page Vault) for court-admissible evidence.

2. Flag and Report the Review to Google

Google has specific policies against spam and fake content. A malicious, fabricated review violates these policies.

Action Item: Go to your Google Business Profile dashboard or the public-facing review page. Click the three dots next to the review and select “Report review” (or “Flag as inappropriate”). You will be asked to choose a violation type. Select the option that best fits the violation (e.g., “Off-topic,” “Spam,” or “Conflict of interest”).
Real-World Example: A business law firm in California received a review from an account that had posted 10 one-star reviews for 10 different business law firms across the state within a 24-hour period. Action: The firm flagged all 10 as “Spam,” providing notes on the suspicious, coordinated activity. Result: Google often removes reviews when a clear pattern of abuse is shown.

3. Monitor and Triage Other Platforms

Malicious actors rarely stick to one platform.

Action Item: Immediately check Yelp, Avvo, Facebook, Martindale-Hubbell, and other key legal directories for the same or similar fake reviews. Use Google Alerts to monitor your firm’s name and key attorneys.

4. The Response (When Appropriate for Non-Law Firms)

While law firms must be extremely cautious due to ethical rules, other businesses (e.g., a marketing agency or financial consultant) have more latitude. If the review is clearly fake, do not engage in a detailed argument.

Action Item (for non-legal businesses): Post a simple, professional, and non-defensive response stating you have no record of the reviewer being a client or customer.
- Example Response: “We take all feedback seriously, but after checking our records thoroughly, we could not find a client matching this name or service description. We suspect this review may not be genuine. We have reported it to Google for review.” This clearly signals to future clients that the review is fraudulent without escalating the conflict.

5. Flood the Zone with Authentic Reviews (The Best Defense)

The most effective long-term strategy is to minimize the visibility of the fake reviews by soliciting a high volume of new, genuine, five-star reviews. A single one-star review is less damaging when buried beneath 50 five-star reviews, thus improving your overall rating.

Action Item: Implement a systematic, ethical system to encourage satisfied clients to leave reviews on your Google Business Profile and other key platforms.

Fake reviews are a persistent digital threat, but they are not an insurmountable one. By adhering to a rigorous, evidence-based protocol—with law firms always prioritizing ethical compliance—you can protect your reputation, maintain your credibility, and ensure that your online presence accurately reflects the quality and integrity of your legal practice.

Stop settling for agencies that treat your marketing budget as a percentage grab and leave you in the dark. Experience the LawClicks difference and see how a truly dedicated, transparent, and results-driven partner can transform your firm’s online presence and client acquisition. Contact us today for a consultation and discover what proactive, innovative, and transparent legal advertising can do for your firm.